Family,Devil Dogs, and Beauty

When {Aunt} Laurene sent me a message that she had Grammie’s “Devil Dogs” recipe and would mail it to me, I didn’t really know what to expect. I don’t know that I have any recollection of ever having had one of these made for me. I also don’t think I ever had {Aunt} Margie’s Whoopi Pies. (Which are the classic referred to Swinimer recipes) I do remember chocolate dipped graham crackers with sprinkles….and I link that to {Aunt} Loretta’s wedding reception. I’m just not certain I went to her wedding reception?

Why are memories fleeting moments of clarity that leave a long trail of unanswered questions?

Did you know that baked goods can sense beauty? You didn’t? Oh, well apparently they can according to one of the women in the chapter I advise. That’s what she told her friend while we were making these and she had mastered the “squishing” of the cookies, apparently it had nothing to do with experience and everything to do with beauty.

Luckily, I had the perfect excuse to make these Devil Dogs when the chapter had a retreat and were asked to bring the desserts! We made so many delightful desserts but the Devil Dogs were certainly a highlight.

An extra special treat (for me!) was that I had someone else to help me take photo’s throughout the recipe. Here’s Ali, my photog for the night.

Now, Grammie’s recipe offers two alternatives for the shaping of these. The first is to do like we did and make them in rounds and “squish” the cookie dough so that it’s flat. The second is to use a cookie press. Now because I believe in full disclosure on this blog, I’m going to admit that it was out of complete laziness that I didn’t use the cookie press. Not only is my cookie press in my storage unit (the perils of living in less than 500 square feet) but the thought of getting said cookie press, cleaning it before and after cookie making, and returning it to storage, made my already burdened brain cringe. So I opted for the circle version which looks more like whoopi pies. They tasted no different, but the cookie press would make a BIG difference in production time, as you would be able to avoid processing through this:

Unless of course you have beauty on your side. In which case you will quickly master squishing the cookies.

In case you can’t tell from the above picture, the dough is very, very sticky. I mixed the dough exactly according to the instructions, and used my hands to mix the dough prior to adding the buttermilk. (And please note, the recipe says to use a glass cup dipped in flour, but it resulted in the same mess and we found sprinkling a bit of flour on top of the cookie and using your fingers left less of a mess. Again, Cookie Press = Easier)

After mixing this stiff dough with my hands, I put the dough back into the mixer and added the buttermilk to whip it all together. The end result of the cookie dough was a very moist, but thick dough. (And the fact that Grammie managed this recipe sans a Kitchen Aid mixer has left me in awe of her abilities!)

The frosting on the inside, is admittedly a bit tricky. It took two attempts to get it right, which was partially because I didn’t realize what was involved and left my friend (the beautiful one) in charge. A word of caution: It goes from soupy to toothpaste consistency in the blink of an eye. Make sure you are monitoring the pan very carefully in the first step. You will want to remove it from heat just when you think it is almost thick enough. Because of this misstep, which I thought could be fixed with some whisking, the first batch of frosting was absolutely disgusting. Because I didn’t want to have to make the frosting a third time, I substituted butter for the shortening because the first batch tasted like straight shortening. The butter worked fine, but it doesn’t whip up the same way that shortening would. For this reason, I plan on making them again with the shortening, but the butter worked just fine and resulted in very delicious Devil Dogs, none the less.

Devil Dogs

Printer Friendly Version


1/2 C Shortening

1 1/2 C Sugar

2 Eggs, beaten

1 tsp Vanilla

2 3/4 C Flour, sifted

1/2 tsp Salt

1 tsp Baking Soda

1/2 C Cocoa

Cream shortening and sugar. Add eggs and vanilla. Sift flour, salt, and cocoa. Add flour mixture to egg mixture, use hands if necessary. Add buttermilk and mix well. You may either drop from tablespoon and flatten with a glass dipped in flour (or fingers), or force through a cookie press using the lady finger tip. Bake in a 350* oven about 10 minutes. Put together, sandwich fashion with the following fillings:


1 1/2 Tbsp Flour

1 Tbsp Cornstarch

1/2 C Milk

Cook to thick paste (but not too thick!) then cool until very thick.

Then add:

1/4 C Shortening

1/2 C Sugar

1 tsp Vanilla

Beat with electric mixer until very light and fluffy.


3 Responses to “Family,Devil Dogs, and Beauty”

  1. CoolMama Says:

    Those look so yummy!

    I just wanted to stop by and thank you for coming by my blog on my SITS day yesterday 🙂

  2. Mary-Jo Says:

    I have been looking for the Whoopi pie recipe, thanks for posting

  3. Sally Says:

    Aunt Edna rocked dog’s !! I had advantage I was at her house more then most.Edna took good Care of me as a teenager.I miss her.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: